Although this release took a few days of delay, it was just because of a hard working week. Anyway, i believe the improvements compensate largely.
The highlights of this release are:
* UPDATED Komodo 9.1 to Komodo 9.2
* UPDATED Zurichess Basel to Zurichess Fribourg
* ADDED Fridolin 2.0.0
* ADDED Rybka 2.3.2a MP as new Windows engine
* ADDED The King 3.50 x64 as new Windows engine
* ADDED Novag Secondo as first tabletop computer engine
* ADDED 50 ELO to all Android engines for better calibration
THE TOPPER:
Komodo 9.2 is clearly stronger than 9.1, in contrast to my initial expectations. After a short hesitation, i replayed all previous Komodo games and 9.2 proved itself. It seems the reptile will stick to the top for a while, at least until Stockfish 7 kicks in.
As mentioned previously, the list needs good calibration vs CCRL and SSDF to be as readable as possible. I always knew it's very complex without the same hardware configuration for Windows engines and use them as trustable calibers.
AMD Athlon x2 4600+ used by CCRL and Intel Quad Core Q6600 used by SSDF have both disappeared. The only solution remaining is to find an acceptable correlation between my Intel Core i7-620M, which has also disappeared from the market long ago.
Past comparisons in benchmarking sites and some available tools show that i7-620M performs better than Athlon and slightly lower than Q6600 with MP. Therefore Windows engines must collect as much ELO as in CCRL but not more than SSDF when tested against Android engines, simply and logically.
Remote connection feature of Chess for Android worked well between Samsung Galaxy Note II and my notebook except for the gauntlets. No way to run like this.
I've had to alter my pairing method to increase automation, by playing vs each Android opponent one by one in separate gauntlets using a collection of related openings instead of consecutive rounds with various opponents using same opening for whole round.
The network engine feature works okay but needs improvement to become more effective. That's a topic i'll come back to in details in a future post.
WINDOWS CALIBERS:
Both Rybka and The King seemed to have some flaws in the calibration task:
Rybka uses hypertrading in MP mode. HT divides each physical core to two logical threads and virtually doubles the total number of threads. Unfortunately, the increase in nodes per seconds doesn't deliver the expected strength increase. HT is not efficient when used with chess engines. I've chosen to tolerate the efficiency loss in Rybka case and keep following because on my notebook there's no option to disable HT via BIOS.
The second caliber is The King. It works well under Arena as a Winboard engine via KingUCI.exe which acts as wb2uci interface. Threads and hash are selectable via wb2uci.eng but strangely the engine hogs the CPU for no reason unless i run it with only 1 thread ouf 4 available. When i use all 4 threads, 3 of them stay loaded after King makes its move. I made sure it's not because of pondering because Fritzmark running in parallel hits the usual score. There must be something wrong keeping the "freed" threads busy. Since it's not comfortable to hear the cooling all the time, relying on 1 CPU rating of CCRL looks better. However, i suspect 1 thread out of 4 on my notebook is not exactly the same as 1 core out 2. It should be something between 0.5 to 1 CPU.
Finally, i've decided to add 50 ELO to all Android engines. Rybka and The King are both ranked well within acceptable error margins for the moment.
In next steps, i'll need some single thread Windows engines to bypass the hyperthreading effect and compare better with other rankings.
SWEET MEMORIES:
If one wonders why Novag Secondo is in the list as one the weakest dedicated chess computers ever sold, i must state it's a very old friend to me. It was my first chess computer in 1993 and still works without problem in 2015!!!
So i could not keep myself from putting it into the pit after all these years. After all, my retro companion needs more weak opponents to move forward a little bit.
BAYES RATINGS AFTER 12088 GAMES PLAYED BY 121 PROGRAMS
Rnk Name T O/S Elo + - Gam Sco Oppo Dra
001 Komodo 9.2 4 A32 3287 45 42 236 82% 3037 28%
002 Stockfish 6 4 A32 3273 44 41 236 80% 3039 30%
003 Critter 1.6a 4 A32 3108 37 36 240 58% 3055 47%
004 Sting SF 4.8.4 JA 4 A32 3078 39 39 240 59% 3007 29%
005 Firenzina 2.4.1 xTreme 4 A32 3074 38 38 220 51% 3063 46%
006 BlackMamba 2.0 4 A32 3053 37 37 238 51% 3047 45%
007 Rybka 2.3.2a mp 4 W64 3009 90 91 40 45% 3051 35%
008 Texel 1.05 4 A32 3008 39 39 242 52% 2991 32%
009 DeepSaros ver.2.3f 1 A32 2995 38 38 246 55% 2957 32%
010 Senpai 1.0 4 A32 2956 40 39 236 54% 2931 28%
011 RobboLito 0.085e4l 4 A32 2937 40 40 230 50% 2938 30%
012 Cheng 4.39 4 A32 2922 39 39 234 50% 2928 32%
013 Hiarcs 13.71 2 IOS 2917 115 111 28 61% 2838 21%
014 Shredder 1.7.0 2 IOS 2883 109 108 26 54% 2863 46%
015 Gaviota v1.0-d 4 A32 2858 37 37 256 49% 2872 29%
016 Hakkapeliitta 3.0 1 A32 2846 38 38 248 50% 2857 31%
017 Arasan 18.0 4 A32 2841 38 38 240 48% 2864 32%
018 Exchess_7.71.beta.JA_xb 4 A32 2838 39 39 228 49% 2861 34%
019 Grapefruit 1.0 4 A32 2816 36 36 250 49% 2822 41%
020 Cyclone 3.4 4 A32 2789 37 37 240 49% 2799 37%
021 DiscoCheck 5.2.1 1 A32 2781 38 38 246 48% 2796 33%
022 Deep Saros 0.9 4 A32 2759 37 37 244 48% 2769 33%
023 Toga II 3.0 1 A32 2752 38 38 232 47% 2776 33%
024 Deuterium v14.3.34.130 1 A32 2733 37 37 238 55% 2695 37%
025 Bobcat 6.4b 4 A32 2723 38 38 246 49% 2734 23%
026 GNU Chess 5.60-32 1 A32 2714 39 39 230 54% 2686 28%
027 Doch32 1.3.4 JA 1 A32 2710 38 38 236 46% 2741 32%
028 Chess Pro 2016.02 2 IOS 2705 112 114 22 45% 2733 55%
029 Fruit reloaded 2.1 1 A32 2703 38 38 220 52% 2695 39%
030 Scorpio_2.7.7.JA_xb 1 A32 2688 42 42 198 51% 2690 31%
031 Murka 3 ARM UCI 1 A32 2687 35 35 258 50% 2689 36%
032 Strelka 5 1 A32 2658 38 38 230 54% 2629 30%
033 The King 3.50 x64 1 W64 2653 48 49 144 41% 2717 31%
034 IvanHoe 9.46b 4 A32 2652 39 39 232 44% 2700 28%
035 Crafty_24.1.JA_xb 1 A32 2623 38 38 244 51% 2614 25%
036 TheMadPrune 1.7.04 4 A32 2620 41 41 204 46% 2649 29%
037 Rodent 1.7 build 1 1 A32 2603 38 38 234 48% 2617 31%
038 Tucano_5.00.JA_xb 1 A32 2595 42 42 190 47% 2616 36%
039 CNVCS 1.2.0 2 IOS 2584 94 95 36 46% 2607 36%
040 RedQueen 1.1.97 4 A32 2561 39 40 232 46% 2590 22%
041 Bison 15.1 1 A32 2561 38 38 236 52% 2547 30%
042 Rhetoric 1.4.1 1 A32 2534 38 38 236 50% 2538 30%
043 Alfil 12.10 1 A32 2533 38 38 232 49% 2539 29%
044 Gull 1.2 arm JA 1 A32 2520 38 38 240 53% 2491 30%
045 Chess Genius 4.0.00 2 IOS 2507 180 198 10 30% 2677 20%
046 Cheese 1.7 1 A32 2489 38 38 242 44% 2531 31%
047 Daydreamer 1.75 JA 1 A32 2477 37 37 238 48% 2486 33%
048 GarboChess 3 1 A32 2472 39 39 236 51% 2464 25%
049 Rotor 0.8 1 A32 2471 38 39 236 46% 2506 28%
050 Fridolin 2.00 4 A32 2461 37 37 238 52% 2442 30%
051 Glaurung Mainz 1 A32 2457 45 45 168 46% 2486 29%
052 Chess Genius 2.6.4 1 A32 2455 224 239 4 38% 2505 75%
053 Danasah_5.07.JA_xb 1 A32 2442 40 39 222 53% 2418 26%
054 BBChess 1.3b JA 4 A32 2417 38 38 238 51% 2406 26%
055 Dirty_030411.JA_xb 1 A32 2405 40 40 222 54% 2376 27%
056 Sloppy_0.23.JA_xb 1 A32 2401 38 38 224 51% 2394 33%
057 Phalanx_XXIV.JA_xb 1 A32 2374 40 40 230 47% 2401 17%
058 GreKo_12.5.JA_xb 1 A32 2367 40 40 222 55% 2328 25%
059 Pepito v1.59 1 A32 2364 37 37 238 50% 2363 33%
060 Pawny_1.0.JA_uci2xb 1 A32 2349 40 39 228 55% 2317 25%
061 BetsabeII_1.47.JA_xb 1 A32 2339 41 41 224 52% 2324 20%
062 Maverick 1.0 JA 1 A32 2314 39 39 244 47% 2336 22%
063 Chess Wise 3.1.7 2 IOS 2298 311 508 2 0% 2507 0%
064 Ifrit_m1.8.JA_uci2xb 1 A32 2297 39 39 224 54% 2262 29%
065 Typhoon_1.0.r358.JA_xb 1 A32 2273 39 39 236 56% 2222 25%
066 Diablo 0.5.1b JA 1 A32 2263 39 39 236 47% 2285 24%
067 Amy_0.8.JA_xb 1 A32 2245 38 39 244 48% 2259 25%
068 Zurichess Fribourg 1 A32 2239 59 60 104 45% 2287 23%
069 Olithink_5.3.2.JA_xb 1 A32 2238 40 40 228 52% 2220 21%
070 Myrddin_0.86.JA_xb 1 A32 2226 42 42 228 51% 2206 21%
071 TJchess 1.1U 1 A32 2203 38 38 250 49% 2204 24%
072 MangoPaola_1.1.JA_xb 1 A32 2188 40 40 234 51% 2177 22%
073 Sungorus 1.4 JA 1 A32 2180 39 39 234 47% 2198 22%
074 Natwarlal_0.14.JA_xb 1 A32 2178 40 40 230 51% 2164 23%
075 KmtChess_1.21.JA_xb 1 A32 2111 41 41 234 49% 2124 20%
076 Bitfoot 1.0.norev 1 A32 2108 39 39 246 51% 2098 25%
077 Scidlet_2.61b2.JA_xb 1 A32 2099 41 41 234 52% 2076 13%
078 NGplay_9.86.JA_xb 1 A32 2086 40 40 230 51% 2079 24%
079 Rattate_Nosferatu.JA_xb 1 A32 2084 41 41 234 49% 2095 18%
080 Resp_0.19.JA_xb 1 A32 2077 40 40 240 52% 2061 19%
081 DanChess_1.04.JA_xb 1 A32 1999 41 41 226 49% 2009 18%
082 Kurt 0.9.2.2 JA 1 A32 1967 40 40 236 51% 1958 21%
083 Robocide 281214.JA 1 A32 1930 41 41 234 47% 1953 17%
084 AdroitChess0.4 JA 1 A32 1910 42 42 226 51% 1897 17%
085 Witz_Alpha21.JA_xb 1 A32 1906 41 41 222 46% 1941 20%
086 Knightcap_3.7F.JA_xb 1 A32 1895 43 42 216 55% 1859 15%
087 BikJump v1.8 1 A32 1895 42 42 224 48% 1908 19%
088 Clubfoot_r2293.JA 1 A32 1893 42 42 220 50% 1898 18%
089 Woodpecker_2.11.JA_xb 1 A32 1886 43 43 218 49% 1892 13%
090 Sjeng_1.12.JA_xb 1 A32 1853 42 42 218 50% 1854 18%
091 Leonidas_r83.JA_xb 1 A32 1852 42 42 216 47% 1877 17%
092 ZCT-0.3.2500 1 A32 1837 41 41 232 45% 1876 15%
093 Faile_1.44.JA_xb 1 A32 1821 41 41 206 49% 1830 30%
094 Cilian_4.14.JA_xb 1 A32 1813 39 39 230 50% 1810 27%
095 Samchess_JA_xb 1 A32 1808 43 43 210 47% 1833 16%
096 Ecce rev. 508 1 A32 1768 42 42 224 49% 1782 17%
097 Colchess_8.0.JA_xb 1 A32 1740 44 44 190 50% 1741 24%
098 Surprise_4.3.b13.JA_xb 1 A32 1738 58 58 122 54% 1706 12%
099 Claudia v. 0.5 1 A32 1731 61 60 118 56% 1681 17%
100 Smash 1.03.JA 1 A32 1730 43 43 230 52% 1694 13%
101 Zzzzzz_3.5.1.JA_xb 1 A32 1646 45 45 178 54% 1589 29%
102 Gunborg_1.0.JA_uci2xb 1 A32 1621 42 42 228 54% 1556 21%
103 Hoichess_0.12.1.JA_xb 1 A32 1621 42 43 218 52% 1581 20%
104 Colossus 4.0 100X 1 C64 1616 236 208 10 80% 1243 20%
105 Rocinante 2.0 JA 1 A32 1608 44 44 218 55% 1522 17%
106 Kitteneitor_060513.JA_xb 1 A32 1606 45 45 176 49% 1576 36%
107 Jester_0.84.JA_xb 1 A32 1604 50 50 168 53% 1538 11%
108 Tscp_1.8.1.AB_xb 1 A32 1594 47 48 176 48% 1587 17%
109 Chenard_2014.07.11.JA_xb 1 A32 1594 47 48 190 42% 1651 12%
110 Pulse 1.5-cpp 1 A32 1579 43 43 222 55% 1481 27%
111 VIRUTOR CHESS 1.1.1 1 A32 1415 48 48 220 52% 1353 10%
112 Superpawn b108 1 A32 1371 55 56 152 49% 1388 16%
113 Chess for Android 1 A32 1371 47 48 227 47% 1359 15%
114 K2 v.075 1 A32 1363 61 61 146 51% 1341 8%
115 Chess Titans 1 W64 1281 211 202 7 57% 1252 29%
116 Trappy_Beowulf_2.0.JA_xb 1 A32 1163 51 53 216 39% 1248 10%
117 Colossus 4.0 1 C64 1118 169 186 14 36% 1203 14%
118 Byak 8.10.14.JA 1 A32 1060 57 60 159 24% 1317 16%
119 Xadreco_5.7.JA_xb 1 A32 972 64 70 154 16% 1334 8%
120 Novag Secondo 1 TTC 821 344 -39 5 40% 900 0%
121 OliveChess 0.2.7 1 A32 556 353-300 128 0% 1438 0%
Rapidroid test platform:
* GT-N7100 1.6 * 4 + 256MB hash: All Android progs,
* Codegen Novatab 1.4* 4 + 256MB: All Android progs,
* Polypad 1010IPS tablet 1.61 * 2 + 128MB: Single thread Android progs
* HTC Diam 528Mhz, 16MB hash: Windows Mobile,
* i7 M620 2.67 Ghz dual + Arena 3.5 + 2GB hash: Windows 64
* iPhone5S A7 1.3 Ghz * 2: iOS programs
* DosBox 1.74: DOS programs,
* WinVICE 2.24: Commodore-64 progs,
* Messtiny UCI adapters or CB-Emu2014: Mephisto programs,
* Openings: 20 ply from Adam Hair or 16 ply from TCEC, no Q exchange, +0.15 to +0.40 evaluated by Stockfish and Komodo at depth 20 minimum, played twice each color.
* Repeating openings and twin games not allowed between two programs
* Tablebases and pondering off
* Time control: 10 to 30 sec/move or 600+0 to 1800+5 or closest known by both programs.